1
BP
$4.29
M: $4.69 P: $5.09 D: $6.49
per gal Gas Prices Near Bay Shore, NY
22 station reports in Suffolk County — snapshot Oct 16, 6:15 AM
Compare reported gas prices in Bay Shore. Each fuel has a report date; confirm the posted pump price before buying.
Find nearby stations and directions on Google Maps ↗. Use the map for distance from your location; our nearby-town distances are approximate.
$4.29 Cheapest
$4.39 Average
22 Stations
2
Mobil
$4.29
M: $4.69 P: $5.09 D: $6.59
per gal 3
Mobil
$4.29
M: $4.85 P: $5.25 D: $6.49
per gal 4
CITGO
Sunoco
1310 5th AveBay Shore, NY
Reported Oct 14, 10:40 AM ET · More than 2 days old
Map & directions ↗ $4.33
P: $5.19
per gal 5
BP
$4.35
6
Exxon
$4.35
M: $4.85 P: $5.29 D: $6.65
per gal 7
Shell
Shell
1701 Union BlvdBay Shore, NY
Reported Oct 14, 11:32 AM ET · More than 2 days old
Map & directions ↗ $4.35
M: $5.27 P: $5.49
per gal 8
Valero
Valero
2307 Union BlvdBay Shore, NY
Reported Oct 12, 4:33 PM ET · More than 2 days old
Map & directions ↗ $4.35
M: $4.79 P: $5.19 D: $6.53
per gal 9
BP
BP
195 Pine Aire DrBay Shore, NY
Reported Oct 14, 10:40 AM ET · More than 2 days old
Map & directions ↗ $4.39
10
Mobil
$4.39
M: $4.99 P: $5.29 D: $6.39
per gal 11
Mobil
$4.39
M: $4.85 P: $5.19 D: $6.49
per gal 12
Shell
Shell
515 E Main StBay Shore, NY
Reported Oct 3, 11:22 PM ET · More than 2 days old
Map & directions ↗ $4.39
M: $4.89 P: $5.39
per gal 13
Shell
Shell
1508 5th AveBay Shore, NY
Reported Oct 9, 8:01 AM ET · More than 2 days old
Map & directions ↗ $4.39
M: $5.09 P: $5.29 D: $6.59
per gal 14
Speedway
$4.39
M: $4.94 P: $5.39 D: $6.59
per gal 15
7-Eleven
$4.39
M: $4.99 P: $5.39 D: $6.57
per gal 16
Sinclair
Sinclair
645 Main StBay Shore, NY
Reported Oct 3, 11:20 PM ET · More than 2 days old
Map & directions ↗ $4.43
M: $4.85 P: $5.07
per gal 17
USA
USA
95 Moffitt BlvdBay Shore, NY
Reported Oct 5, 10:28 PM ET · More than 2 days old
Map & directions ↗ $4.43
M: $4.89 P: $5.27 D: $6.63
per gal 18
Exxon
Exxon
172 Howells RdBay Shore, NY
Reported Oct 3, 9:23 PM ET · More than 2 days old
Map & directions ↗ $4.49
M: $4.99 P: $5.39
per gal 19
Exxon
Exxon
1501 5th AveBay Shore, NY
Reported Oct 2, 3:14 PM ET · More than 2 days old
Map & directions ↗ $4.49
P: $5.39
per gal 20
Shell
Shell
168 Howells RdBay Shore, NY
Reported Oct 3, 11:10 AM ET · More than 2 days old
Map & directions ↗ $4.49
D: $6.68
per gal 21
USA
USA Gas
1171 Sunrise HwyBay Shore, NY
Reported Oct 3, 11:43 AM ET · More than 2 days old
Map & directions ↗ $4.56
P: $5.59
per gal 22
76
—
M: $5.09 P: $5.39 D: $6.39
per gal More Cheap Gas Near Bay Shore
Other reported prices nearby. Distances are estimates between town centers, not driving distances or distance from you.
- Speedway Islip · ~1.8 mi between town centers$4.19Reported Oct 15, 4:42 PM ET
- Sunoco Islip · ~1.8 mi between town centers$4.39Reported Oct 10, 9:13 PM ET · More than 2 days old
- Valero Islip · ~1.8 mi between town centers$4.39Reported Oct 10, 9:13 PM ET · More than 2 days old
- Mobil Islip · ~1.8 mi between town centers$4.49Reported Oct 12, 6:48 AM ET · More than 2 days old
- BP Babylon · ~4.7 mi between town centers$4.83Reported Oct 7, 5:52 PM ET · More than 2 days old
Bay Shore Gas Price Context
The Suffolk County average for regular in this set of reports is $4.37/gal versus $4.35 across all of Long Island. If your commute runs along Sunrise Highway or Southern State Parkway, check prices at both ends of the trip — compare each price report date and any membership or payment requirements. Hit a pothole on the way? The Bay Shore tire shop directory shows listed hours and contact details, and our roadside safety analysis covers what to do if it happens on a parkway.
FAQ — Gas in Bay Shore
Where is the lowest reported gas price near Bay Shore?
The lowest reported regular price in Bay Shore is $4.29/gal regular at BP. Reported Oct 6, 7:49 AM ET · More than 2 days old. Confirm the price at the station.
Is gas in Suffolk County cheaper than the Long Island average?
Suffolk County has a reported average of $4.37/gal regular versus $4.35 island-wide — above the average of tracked Long Island reports. Prices can have different report dates; confirm before buying.
How often are Bay Shore gas prices updated?
The snapshot was exported Oct 16, 6:15 AM. Each fuel has its own report time. Reports older than 14 days are omitted; prices can change before the next report.