Privacy update — September 18, 2026: Identifying details have been removed under our victim privacy policy.
Incident location, Long Island
What Happened
Wesley Sitar, a 45-year-old man from Nesconset, was arrested around 2:30 a.m. Friday morning after allegedly driving drunk and crashing into another vehicle on East Deer Park Road in Elwood, according to police. The collision left a 21-year-old man from Oakdale with serious injuries requiring hospitalization.
Police say the crash occurred as Sitar attempted to turn from westbound East Jericho Turnpike onto East Deer Park Road in the early morning hours. The specific circumstances of how the two vehicles collided during this turning maneuver have not been detailed by investigators, but the impact was severe enough to cause significant harm to the younger driver.
The 21-year-old Oakdale resident suffered serious injuries in the collision and was transported to a local hospital for treatment, though police have not released specific details about the nature or extent of his injuries. His current condition remains unknown as the investigation continues.
Following the crash, Sitar was taken into custody and faces multiple charges stemming from the incident. Police arrested him on suspicion of driving while intoxicated, indicating that field sobriety tests or other evidence suggested he was under the influence of alcohol at the time of the collision. Additionally, investigators discovered what they allege was a billy club in Sitar’s vehicle, leading to an additional charge of criminal possession of a weapon.
The intersection where the crash occurred has drawn attention from local business owners who say the area presents ongoing safety challenges for drivers. Mario Rapo, manager at nearby Maddaloni Jewelers, described the intersection of East Jericho Turnpike and East Deer Park Road as particularly hazardous. “This intersection is always lethal. Not only just in the daytime. It’s not an easy place to be around or drive around, especially at night,” Rapo told News 12.
Rapo emphasized that the dangers are amplified during overnight hours when visibility is reduced, making reckless driving behaviors even more dangerous. He characterized actions like cutting off other vehicles as “insanity” in the early hours when visibility is low, suggesting that the challenging intersection geometry combined with poor lighting conditions creates a recipe for serious accidents.
Sitar was arraigned Saturday morning on the multiple charges, appearing before a judge to hear the formal accusations against him. The timing of the arraignment, occurring the day after the Friday morning crash, indicates that prosecutors moved quickly to process the case through the court system.
Location & Road Context
The crash occurred at the intersection of East Jericho Turnpike and East Deer Park Road in Elwood, an area that local business owners have identified as particularly dangerous for motorists. East Jericho Turnpike serves as a major east-west arterial road through central Long Island, carrying significant traffic volumes throughout the day and night.
The intersection’s geometry and lighting conditions appear to create challenges for drivers attempting turning maneuvers, particularly during overnight hours when visibility is reduced. Local merchants familiar with the area have observed recurring safety issues at this location, suggesting that the Friday morning crash may not be an isolated incident at this intersection.
Investigation & Legal Proceedings
Sitar faces two distinct charges following his arrest: driving while intoxicated and criminal possession of a weapon. The DWI charge stems from the alleged impaired driving that police say caused the collision, while the weapon charge relates to investigators’ discovery of what they describe as a billy club found in his vehicle.
The 45-year-old Nesconset man appeared for arraignment Saturday morning, where he formally heard the charges against him. Court proceedings will determine the specific penalties he may face if convicted on either or both charges. The investigation into the crash circumstances continues as prosecutors build their case.